Go to Database Directory || Go to CISG Table of Contents || Go to Case Search Form || Go to Bibliography

CISG CASE PRESENTATION

Netherlands 19 December 1991 District Court Roermond (Fallini Stefano v. Foodik)
[Cite as: http://cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cases/911219n1.html]

Primary source(s) for case presentation: F. De Ly; Michael R. Will; UNCITRAL abstract; Unilex abstract


Case Table of Contents


Case identification

DATE OF DECISION: 19911219 (19 December 1991)

JURISDICTION: Netherlands

TRIBUNAL: Rb Roermond [Rb = Arrondissementsrechtbank = District Court]

JUDGE(S): Unavailable

CASE NUMBER/DOCKET NUMBER: 900336

CASE NAME: Fallini Stefano & Co. S.N.C. v. Foodik BV

CASE HISTORY: Unavailable

SELLER'S COUNTRY: Italy (plaintiff)

BUYER'S COUNTRY: Germany (defendant)

GOODS INVOLVED: Cheese


Case abstract

NETHERLANDS: Rb Roermond 19 December 1991

Case law on UNCITRAL texts (CLOUT) abstract no. 98

Reproduced with permission from UNCITRAL

The plaintiff, an Italian seller, sued demanding payment of the price of cheese sold and delivered to the defendant, a Dutch buyer. The [buyer] counterclaimed damages and reduction of the price on the ground of non-conformity of the goods with contract specifications.

Applying Dutch private international law, the court found that CISG was applicable as the law of Italy, i.e. the country where the seller had its place of business at the time of the conclusion of the contract (art. 1(1)(b) CISG). The court held that the reasonableness o[f] the time of giving notice depended on the nature of the goods involved. In this case, the court found that the buyer had notified the seller of the non-conformity of the cheese shortly after delivery, which in the view of the court was a reasonable time in view of the fact that cheese is a perishable item (articles 38 and 39 CISG).

The court further found: that the buyer did not notify the seller about the nature of the defect, i.e. that the cheese was infested; and that the fact that the cheese was frozen and not described in the contract was not sufficient reason for not examining it. It was held that, in order for the seller not to be able to rely on articles 38 and 39 CISG, the buyer had to prove its allegation that the seller knew or could not have been unaware that the cheese was infested already at the time it was frozen (art. 40 CISG). The court observed that, if the buyer were able to meet that burden of proof, it would be entitled to a reduction of the purchase price pursuant to article 50 CISG.

Go to Case Table of Contents


Classification of issues present

APPLICATION OF CISG: Yes [Article 1(1)(b)]

APPLICABLE CISG PROVISIONS AND ISSUES

Key CISG provisions at issue: Articles 38 ; 39 ; 40 ; [Also cited: Article 50 ]

Classification of issues using UNCITRAL classification code numbers:

38A [Buyer's obligation to examine goods: time for examining goods];

39A1 ; 39A2 ; 39A3 [Requirement to notify seller of lack of conformity: within reasonable time; Specification of nature of non-conformity; Exception in case of seller's knowledge];

40A [Seller's knowledge of non-conformity (seller fails to disclose known non-conformity): burden of proof]

Descriptors: Examination of goods ; Lack of conformity notice, timeliness ; Lack of conformity notice, specificity ; Lack of conformity known to seller ; Burden of proof

Go to Case Table of Contents


Editorial remarks

Go to Case Table of Contents


Citations to other abstracts, case texts and commentaries

CITATIONS TO OTHER ABSTRACTS OF DECISION

English: Unilex database <http://www.unilex.info/case.cfm?pid=1&do=case&id=34&step=Abstract>

French: Revue de Droit des Affaires Internationales (1995) 1013-1014 [CLOUT abstract]

Italian: Diritto del Commercio Internazionale (1994) 851 No. 32

Polish: Hermanowski/Jastrzebski, Konwencja Narodow Zjednoczonych o umowach miedzynarodowej sprzedazy towarow (Konwencja wiedenska) - Komentarz (1997) 247

CITATIONS TO TEXT OF DECISION

Original language (Dutch): Nederlands Internationaal Privaatrecht (NIPR) 1994, No. 394 [665-667]; Unilex database <http://www.unilex.info/case.cfm?pid=1&do=case&id=34&step=FullText>

Translation: Unavailable

CITATIONS TO COMMENTS ON DECISION

English: Ferrari, International Legal Forum (4/1998) 138-255 [238 n.909 n.911 (notice of lack of conformity)]; Honnold, Uniform Law for International Sales (1999) 274 [Art. 38 (timeliness of examination)]; Lookofsky, Understanding the CISG in Scandinavia (1996) 62 n.91; Bernstein/Lookofsky, CISG/Europe (1997) 62 n.63, 66; for a survey of close to 100 judicial and arbitral rulings on Article 39(1), go to the 1998 Pace essay on this subject by Camilla Baasch Andersen; Kuoppala, Examination of the Goods under the CISG and the Finnish Sale of Goods Act (2000) 4.4.1.4, 4.8 [analysis of related articles 38, 39, 40 and 44 (includes digests of relevant material in many CISG cases; also digests cases under a domestic sales code that is patterned, for the most part, after the CISG)]; Bernstein & Lookofsky, Understanding the CISG in Europe, 2d ed., Kluwer (2003) § 4-9 n.118, n.134; Larry A. DiMatteo et al., 34 Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business (Winter 2004) 299-440 at nn.345, 370, 399, 585; CISG-AC advisory opinion on Examination of the Goods and Notice of Non-Conformity [7 June 2004] (cases cited in addendum to opinion); [2004] S.A. Kruisinga, (Non-)conformity in the 1980 UN Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods: a uniform concept?, Intersentia at 67, 79, 185; [2005] Schlechtriem & Schwenzer ed., Commentary on UN Convention on International Sale of Goods, 2d (English) ed., Oxford University Press, Art. 38 para. 14 Art. 40 para. 12

Dutch: van der Velden, Weekblad voor privaatrecht, notariaat en registratie (WPNR) 1994, 564 [565-566]

French: Witz, Les premières applications jurisprudentielles du droit uniforme de la vente internationale (L.G.D.J., Paris: 1995) 92-93 n.62, 107 n.119

German: Schlechtriem, Internationales UN-Kaufrecht (1996) 88 n.68

Greek: Witz/Kapnopoulou, Ellenike epitheorese europaikou dicaiou (1995) 561 [575 n.49]

Go to Case Table of Contents
Pace Law School Institute of International Commercial Law - Last updated August 15, 2005
Comments/Contributions
Go to Database Directory || Go to CISG Table of Contents || Go to Case Search Form || Go to Bibliography