Matchup of CISG Article 46 with ULIS/ULF Go to Database Directory || Go to CISG Table of Contents

LEGISLATIVE HISTORY

CISG ANTECEDENTS

Match-up of CISG article 46 with ULIS provisions


     CISG Article 46                         ULIS Article 24 
                                                      
1. The buyer may require           1. Where the seller fails 
performance by the seller of       to perform his obligations 
his obligation unless the buyer    as regards the date or the 
has resorted to a remedy which     place of delivery, the buyer 
is inconsistent with this          may, as provided in Articles 
requirement.                       25 to 32: 
 
2. If the goods do not conform       (a) require performance of 
with the contract the buyer may          the contract by the seller; 
require delivery of substitute 
goods only if the lack of conformity (b) declare the contract avoided. 
constitutes a fundamental breach 
of contract and a request for      2. The buyer may also claim 
substitute goods is made either    damages as provided in Article 
in conjunction with notice given   82 or in Articles 84 to 87. 
under article 39 or within a 
reasonable time thereafter.        3. In no case shall the seller be 
                                   entitled to apply to a court or 
3. If the goods do not conform     arbitral tribunal to grant him a 
with the contract, the buyer may   period of grace. 
require the seller to remedy the 
lack of conformity by repair,  
unless this is unreasonable    
having regard to all the       
circumstances.  A request for repair 
must be made either in              
conjunction with notice given under  
article 39 or within a reasonable    
time thereafter. 
 
SEE ALSO: 
 
ULIS Article 25  
 
The buyer shall not be entitled to require performance of the contract 
by the seller, if it is in conformity with usage and reasonably  
possible for the buyer to purchase goods to replace those to which 
the contact relates.  In this case the contract shall be ipso facto 
avoided as from the time when such purchase should be effected. 
 
ULIS Article 26(1)  
 
Where the failure to deliver the goods at the date fixed amount 
to a fundamental breach of the contract, the buyer may either require  
performance by the seller or declare the contract avoided. He 
shall inform the seller of his decision within a reasonable time; 
otherwise the contract shall be ipso facto avoided. 
 

SEE ALSO Articles 27(1), 30(1), 41(1(a), 42(1), 51, 52(1), 55(2) of ULIS


Pace Law School Institute of International Commercial Law - May 22, 2001
Comments/Contributions

Go to Database Directory || Go to CISG Table of Contents